Disney is making a film version of the Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, due out around Christmas, and complete with the “Jesus Cat” to borrow a phrase from a certain fun-loving cynical friend of mine.
Apparently the Christian themes that C.S. Lewis wove through the original will be staying in the movie, which is fine as far as I am concerned. Narnia is no “Passion of Christ”, in that it remembered to be art first and religious second, much like some of those classic renaissance paintings.
No, the thing that has me cheesed about the upcoming Narnia film is this trailer (scroll to “Teaser Trailer #1): this movie is trying very hard to be a cross between Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings (Look! It’s Aragorn, Gimli and Legolas! Or is that Harry, Ron and Hermione?). It’s almost as if some execs at Disney sat down and said “Hey, fantasy movies are doing really well, look at LotR and HP. Why don’t we do something like that? Hmm, what famous fantasy novel can we go out and license?”. But that never happens in real life, does it?
Also, once again, epic battle scenes. Now, I know there were battles in Narnia, but that’s not the part that stands out in my memory. Sure, the inevitable conflict between good and evil is a necessary part of the story, but I am worried it’s going to be a bit like the battle at Helm’s Deep in The Two Towers, which expanded from one chapter to half of the movie. This preoccupation that Hollywood has with massive CGI armies is a bit unhealthy, if for no other reason than nine times out of ten the result is really boring.
Whenever someone adapts a book I really liked into film or television I don’t get excited, I get nervous. Sometimes it turns out okay (Lord of the Rings), other times it gets slaughtered (Earthsea miniseries anyone? Okay, I will admit, I didn’t actually watch that, I wanted to preserve my memory of the novels unmolested). I wonder how Narnia will turn out…